Lawsuit on Propecia

iwttgpn

New Member
Reaction score
0
A Connecticut law firm has filed a lawsuit against pharmaceutical manufacturer Merck & Co. on behalf of men who have taken Propecia, a prescription drug that combats hair loss but, its critics say, can also cause severe side effects such as sexual dysfunction and mental impairment.

Attorney Edward Jazlowiecki of Bristol has joined two other firms, in New Jersey and New York, in filing the suit, which alleges that Merck has failed to fully disclose the serious side effects of Propecia and failed to adjust its warnings in the American market even after European regulators forced the company to carry a stronger warning label.

Propecia, which is also marketed under the brand name Proscar, was originally introduced to treat men with enlarged prostates, but it won FDA approval in 1997 for the treatment of male pattern hair loss after patients noticed its restorative powers with hair. The drug's active ingredient is finasteride, which can help reduce the levels of the substance on the scalp that leads to hair loss.

But in many men, Jazlowiecki said, finasteride also reduces sexual function and leads to mental and emotional symptoms like anxiety attacks and insomnia that do not go away years after men stop using the drug.

Get Our iPhone & BlackBerry Apps -- FREE!

"The same mechanism in the hormone system that controls hair loss also controls sexual function and a patient's mental state, and this drug has had devastating effects and destroyed the lives of men who have taken it," Jazlowiecki said. "Merck knew this, and their claims that the negative effects of the drug go away once you stop using it are false. The damage to these men appears to be permanent, even after five years of taking the drug."

When contacted by The Courant, Merck released a statement that said, "The company intends to vigorously defend against the lawsuit."

Jazlowiecki said that one of the plaintiffs in his suit suffered such severe symptoms that his wife left him, and that another plaintiff suffered from a loss of concentration that forced him to drop out of law school. Jazlowiecki's complaint, filed in U.S. District Court in New Jersey, where Merck's U.S. headquarters are located, also quotes American and European doctors who have passionately argued against the drug, citing many of the severe side effects listed in the lawsuit.

Similar experiences are described on a website devoted to men who have suffered side effects from the drug, http://www.propeciahelp.com.

One Connecticut patient, who plans to join the lawsuit as soon as lawyers finish examining his medical records, said that he stopped taking Propecia three years ago after experiencing trouble breathing, sexual dysfunction, anxiety attacks and memory loss. He asked not to be named because his mother still does not know of the severe side effects the drug caused.

"I was a happy, athletic person before I started taking this drug, but now it has ruined my life," the plaintiff said. "The hardest part is going to doctors and describing my condition and they don't believe me. They believe all of the material that has been sent out by the FDA and Merck and just send me home with a prescription for anti-depressants."

On its Propecia website, under "possible side effects," Merck does have a warning, which reads:

"A small number of men had sexual side effects, with each occurring in less than 2% of men. These include less desire for sex, difficulty in achieving an erection, and a decrease in the amount of semen. These side effects went away in men who stopped taking PROPECIA because of them."

But doctors that Jazlowiecki quotes in his lawsuit insist that symptoms persist after patients stop using Propecia, and might be permanent.
 

Jstalkens

New Member
Reaction score
0
that's bad news, but will be difficult to prove. With anything treatment , especially a prescription drug you are going to have to expect side effects. They cannot possibly predict how each person is going to react to the drug. How many drugs out there cause sexual dysfunction, and increased anxiety? I mean come on. Do people have to sue for everything? Looks like an easy way out to me.
 

Mens Rea

Senior Member
Reaction score
6
Jstalkens said:
that's bad news, but will be difficult to prove. With anything treatment , especially a prescription drug you are going to have to expect side effects. They cannot possibly predict how each person is going to react to the drug. How many drugs out there cause sexual dysfunction, and increased anxiety? I mean come on. Do people have to sue for everything? Looks like an easy way out to me :gay: .

Easy way out of what exactly?

People have had their body's wrecked by this stuff you arrogant insincere a**h**.
 

Ende

Senior Member
Reaction score
10
Merck is going down, it's just a question of time. I've my own plan, and know exactly how to expose them. No more lies.
 

Cassin

Senior Member
Reaction score
78
Mens Rea said:
you arrogant insincere a**hole.

easy easy easy


One big problem they will face in courts is people who

1. Self diagnosed themselves with male pattern baldness
2. Ordered drugs off the internet

Basically this allows MERK to throw up their hands and say something like "we can't be held responsible for counterfeit drugs taken from the internet"
 

Nene

Senior Member
Reaction score
12
Cassin said:
Mens Rea said:
you arrogant insincere a**hole.

easy easy easy


One big problem they will face in courts is people who

1. Self diagnosed themselves with male pattern baldness
2. Ordered drugs off the internet

Basically this allows MERK to throw up their hands and say something like "we can't be held responsible for counterfeit drugs taken from the internet"

Also, if you are taking a generic finasteride, you will not be able to sue Merck. You have to prove it was their finasteride that gave you problems.
 

Ende

Senior Member
Reaction score
10
and you must have used Propecia, not Proscar. Luckily, I was diagnosed by a dermatologist and prescribed Propecia by him.

However, this is not the way to overcome Merck. We need the authorities to demand a blood test before doctors prescribe Propecia. Hard evidence will be gathered in no time.
 

Mens Rea

Senior Member
Reaction score
6
Yeah most people didn't use propecia - myself included.

We did rely on their study and their marketing though but i guess they didn't owe non-propecia users any duty of care.
 

Mens Rea

Senior Member
Reaction score
6
You think so?

I'm not convinced. I mean its a generic drug usually manufactured over in Inida.

I don't know anything about their laws over there but i bet they wouldn't be very helpful for people in our position.

End of the day it is MERCK that promoted the drug and pushed their study findings which people in turn relied on when making their decision to use the drug.

The liability seems less clear with other manufacturers. I mean, you could easily source a much stronger drug than finasteride to completely mess you up - could you sue them, too?

Those companies didn't really make any representations as regards safety etc unlike MERCK. I think that's the killer alongside the fact they aren't based in India etc!
 

Nene

Senior Member
Reaction score
12
Mens Rea said:
You think so?

I'm not convinced. I mean its a generic drug usually manufactured over in Inida.

I don't know anything about their laws over there but i bet they wouldn't be very helpful for people in our position.

End of the day it is MERCK that promoted the drug and pushed their study findings which people in turn relied on when making their decision to use the drug.

The liability seems less clear with other manufacturers. I mean, you could easily source a much stronger drug than finasteride to completely mess you up - could you sue them, too?

Those companies didn't really make any representations as regards safety etc unlike MERCK. I think that's the killer alongside the fact they aren't based in India etc!

I think your out of luck if you used those Indian drugs. But the problem with suing American manufacturers of generic finasteride is that it is only produced in 5 mg tablets for bph. I'm not sure if you can sue after being sneaky and taking the 5mg bph pill and cutting it up? I'd have to read up on case law for this kind of thing. Mes Rea are you a lawyer?
 

Ende

Senior Member
Reaction score
10
People who have used Finpecia should sue Cipla. Generics or not, the manufacturer is responsible for adverse effects caused by their drugs. It shouldn't be a problem, as long as a doctor prescribed the medication.

I can't explain how relieved I am, to know that I was prescribed Propecia by a dermatologist. I feel sorry for everyone who wasn't.
 

Mens Rea

Senior Member
Reaction score
6
Nene said:
Mens Rea said:
You think so?

I'm not convinced. I mean its a generic drug usually manufactured over in Inida.

I don't know anything about their laws over there but i bet they wouldn't be very helpful for people in our position.

End of the day it is MERCK that promoted the drug and pushed their study findings which people in turn relied on when making their decision to use the drug.

The liability seems less clear with other manufacturers. I mean, you could easily source a much stronger drug than finasteride to completely mess you up - could you sue them, too?

Those companies didn't really make any representations as regards safety etc unlike MERCK. I think that's the killer alongside the fact they aren't based in India etc!

I think your out of luck if you used those Indian drugs. But the problem with suing American manufacturers of generic finasteride is that it is only produced in 5 mg tablets for bph. I'm not sure if you can sue after being sneaky and taking the 5mg bph pill and cutting it up? I'd have to read up on case law for this kind of thing. Mes Rea are you a lawyer?

I am actually, funny you should ask Is it the name that gave it away?

This stuff is very much outside my "expertise" if you should dare to use such a clumbsy word :0
 

Mens Rea

Senior Member
Reaction score
6
Enden said:
People who have used Finpecia should sue Cipla. Generics or not, the manufacturer is responsible for adverse effects caused by their drugs. It shouldn't be a problem, as long as a doctor prescribed the medication.

I can't explain how relieved I am, to know that I was prescribed Propecia by a dermatologist. I feel sorry for everyone who wasn't.


Why? I mean, even if such "claims" do go through eventually, the more money you get will just be a reflection of how messed up you are/ how poor a quality of life you now lead.

For me, its immaterial because all i care about is getting better right now.

I personally dont blame Dr Reddy's or Cipia whatsoever. I mean, they just supplied generic durgs that tehre was a demand for. The reason we all used these companies was because of MERCK ironically enough. MERCK are the ones who pushed its usage for male pattern baldness and it's their study we loosely relied on. I blame myself much more than any drug manufacturers in India.
 

Ende

Senior Member
Reaction score
10
What do you think 10 years of a man's life, from 20 to 30 is worth? Even if we find a solution for everyone, some people have lost many years of their lives. What about families who have lost someone because of suicide. What's a life worth? It's a lot more to it than compensation for disability, but since we're talking about it; what's your dick worth? Personally I don't give a sh*t, and would rather be dead.
 

Mens Rea

Senior Member
Reaction score
6
Enden said:
What do you think 10 years of a man's life, from 20 to 30 is worth? Even if we find a solution for everyone, some people have lost many years of their lives. What about families who have lost someone because of suicide. What's a life worth? It's a lot more to it than compensation for disability, but since we're talking about it; what's your dick worth? Personally I don't give a sh*t, and would rather be dead.

Rather be dead than having ED??
 

Cassin

Senior Member
Reaction score
78
The only people who have a valid argument are those who take propecia specifically as prescribed by a Dr.

Off label use or crap bought overseas from some internet site makes a legal argument invalid I would think.
 

Ende

Senior Member
Reaction score
10
Mens Rea said:
Enden said:
What do you think 10 years of a man's life, from 20 to 30 is worth? Even if we find a solution for everyone, some people have lost many years of their lives. What about families who have lost someone because of suicide. What's a life worth? It's a lot more to it than compensation for disability, but since we're talking about it; what's your dick worth? Personally I don't give a sh*t, and would rather be dead.

Rather be dead than having ED??
I would rather be dead, than not being able to have sex.
 

Nene

Senior Member
Reaction score
12
Mens Rea said:
Nene said:
[quote="Mens Rea":ruw9cmlf]You think so?

I'm not convinced. I mean its a generic drug usually manufactured over in Inida.

I don't know anything about their laws over there but i bet they wouldn't be very helpful for people in our position.

End of the day it is MERCK that promoted the drug and pushed their study findings which people in turn relied on when making their decision to use the drug.

The liability seems less clear with other manufacturers. I mean, you could easily source a much stronger drug than finasteride to completely mess you up - could you sue them, too?

Those companies didn't really make any representations as regards safety etc unlike MERCK. I think that's the killer alongside the fact they aren't based in India etc!

I think your out of luck if you used those Indian drugs. But the problem with suing American manufacturers of generic finasteride is that it is only produced in 5 mg tablets for bph. I'm not sure if you can sue after being sneaky and taking the 5mg bph pill and cutting it up? I'd have to read up on case law for this kind of thing. Mes Rea are you a lawyer?

I am actually, funny you should ask Is it the name that gave it away?

This stuff is very much outside my "expertise" if you should dare to use such a clumbsy word :0[/quote:ruw9cmlf]

The name gave it away but also when you said "duty of care."
 

Mens Rea

Senior Member
Reaction score
6
Enden said:
Mens Rea said:
Enden said:
What do you think 10 years of a man's life, from 20 to 30 is worth? Even if we find a solution for everyone, some people have lost many years of their lives. What about families who have lost someone because of suicide. What's a life worth? It's a lot more to it than compensation for disability, but since we're talking about it; what's your dick worth? Personally I don't give a sh*t, and would rather be dead.

Rather be dead than having ED??
I would rather be dead, than not being able to have sex.

Enden, firstly I don't think you mean that. There is much more to life than sex. I don't think i need to qualify that statement, either.

Secondly, you can have sex so we aren't even speaking about you I'm assuming?

Thirdly, there's always ways around impotence , all the way up to an inflatable penis.... But i'm thinking more levitra for you - this stuff seems to be the stuff that works for almost everyone on propeciahelp where cialis and v**** fails.

It's the mental sides that people get is what really can make people suicidal it would seem.
 
Top