Rogaine Foam Questions - 'Trying' it sans DHT blocker

[prator]

I was using Propecia and it was working well for me, but I couldn't get used to the side effects. You can read my story here:
http://www.hairlosstalk.com/discussions ... 890#292890

My current regimen is in my sig, but it mostly consists of using Saw Palmetto and Beta-Sistorel. It's slowed my hair loss down, but regrowth hasn't happened.

I've been thinking of using Rogaine foam.


Questions

1. Is there any problem with using the Rogaine foam without a DHT blocker like Propecia or Duasteride? I have read that Rogaine merely grows new, thin hair follicles. If I just use this, won't the rest of my "normal" hair simply fall out if I don't find some way to block enough of the DHT?

2. Is there any proof that any of the topical solutions block DHT and thus proof that they help to either regrow or maintain hair?

Back in the day my dad used Rogaine to prevent further hair loss, but from what I can tell, it doesn't prevent further hair loss but actually just promotes growth of new hair follicles that may or may not be as thick as your old hair follicles. Am I right or have I missed something.

Much, much thanks to anyone who takes time out of their day to help me sort this out.

Prator

 

[Bryan]

1. Is there any problem with using the Rogaine foam without a DHT blocker like Propecia or Duasteride? I have read that Rogaine merely grows new, thin hair follicles. If I just use this, won't the rest of my "normal" hair simply fall out if I don't find some way to block enough of the DHT?

I think what you said in that last sentence is probably correct. Minoxidil doesn't appear to interfere with the fundamental balding process, it just artifically stimulates a little extra growth. So if you don't use anything else besides minoxidil, I think the balding process will probably continue its inevitable course. All minoxidil probably does is buy you a little extra time.

2. Is there any proof that any of the topical solutions block DHT and thus proof that they help to either regrow or maintain hair?

There are various levels of "proof", but yes, there are scientific tests and studies showing that some of the topicals seem to have a favorable effect on hair.

Back in the day my dad used Rogaine to prevent further hair loss, but from what I can tell, it doesn't prevent further hair loss but actually just promotes growth of new hair follicles that may or may not be as thick as your old hair follicles. Am I right or have I missed something.

I think that's pretty accurate. Rogaine is a palliative agent which (apparently) doesn't really interfere with the fundamental balding process.