Someone find the blood flow rate to the scalp in mL/min.
I believe the problem with topical finasteride has two branches:
A: problems for people with finasteride side effects: 1. It leaves the scalp into the blood stream to fast. 2. Once it stops entering through the skin, and the blood has rinsed the excess into the main body and fresh blood is passing by, diffusion (always in the direction of higher concentration to lower concentration) causes finasteride to diffuse back out of the follicle and into the blood before it has bonded with most 5ar2 in the follicle.
B: problems for people who want a huge concentration in their scalp, but
don't want a huge concentration in their body: 1. Not a high enough percent of finasteride is absorbed through the skin, wasting most of it. 2. the same problems as in group B.
Goals:
To avoid side effects, most sensitive people need less than 0.04 mg entering their body, and probably as little as 0.01mg, based on graphs of DHT inhibition vs dose, and assuming DHT inhibition causes the side effects. However, they want the same concentration in their scalp that betweem 0.05 and 1mg orally would give.
Scalp megadosers would like to have the concentration in their scalp that 30mg orally would give, to REALLY inhibit DHT, but they'd prefer to pay for and subject their body to 1mg per day.
Both need it enter the scalp slowly and evenly over at about 3 hours. If it is all delivered at once, it just goes into circulation and then the follicle has none around unless the body is full enough for some to come back. It takes about 1-3 hours for most 5ar2 to bond to finasteride (Bryan, is that right?), so our vehicle must deliver the dose slowly over time, to keep the finasteride concentration in the micro arteries around the follicles high enough to balance the finasteride diffusing out of the follicles into the micro veins.
We can safely assume that all finasteride that enters the skin will go systemic eventually. Our goal should be to take advantage of the small volume of the scalp compared to the body and the flow rate of the drug into the scalp so that the concentration of drug in the small scalp is greater than the concentration in the body, even though there is more drug in the body than in the scalp.
Most of the drug enters through the pours. That is common pharmaceutical knowledge for most topicals. While a good diagram might tell us how much finasteride is likely to diffuse into the follicle directly instead of first into the blood, we know that if it has to leave the scalp eventually, it will leave through a micro vein. When the drug first enters, it will diffuse to the follicle and other structures, and it will diffuse down to the micro arteries and veins in equal amounts (50-50 chance of each). The half that enters micro veins is wasted, and the half that enters micro arteries will enter follicles and other structures so that the whole scalp is hit. Remember that veins go from the cells to the heart and arteries go from the heart to the cells.
I think the whole body has a volume of 75 L (for a 75kg person) and the blood has a volume of 11 L (please correct me on that).
For people with side effects, if everyone can handle 0.01mg per day, then that is the most we can have them absorb per day. We need a vehicle that will give them 0.01mg in 3 hours. So if our vehicle has a 0.5% penetration rate, then each dose of solution should have 2mg, which is affordable. We need a vehicle that is steady over 3 hours and has at least a 0.2% penetration rate, which is one proscar pill per day. This is very feasible.
Next, we have to know if this dose will be therapudic. In order for it to be therapudic, the finasteride in the blood in the micro arteries must be kept at at least the same concentration that 0.05mg/day orally would give. I'll say 0.2 mg/day orally, just to be safe, and will throw out the 60% absorption of the gut for further safety. We know that half our dose will be wasted since it will go straight into the micro veins. We need to know the blood flow rate of blood in the male pattern baldness part of the scalp. Someone needs to find the blood flow rate to the whole scalp, in mL per minute, which is probably in a reference somewhere.
We need to multiply the blood flow rate times 3 hours to know how much blood will flow through the follicles in 3 hours. Next, we divide 0.2mg by 75 liters, or make that 50 liters to be safe and account for bones, to get the finasteride concentration that is therapeudic. Next, we multiply this concentration by the 3 hour blood volume to get the mg finasteride that is needed to be therapudic. For the topical to work for people who are sensitive to finasteride, the number must me less than 0.01 mg.
Now 0.01 mg may be an underestimate. Some people may handle 0.05 or even 0.1 mg/day. Also, the assumption of 0.2 mg/day for therapudic needs is an overestimate, since 0.05 mg/day lowers DHT as much as 1mg/day, and any DHT inhibition is better than nothing, especially if it can be applied at the same time as minoxidil just by modifying minoxidil's vehicle.
Find me the blood flow rate through through the scalp (and I'll divide by 2 or 3 to just have the male pattern baldness area) and find a vehicle that has at least 0.2% penetration steadily over 3 hours, and I will tell you how much finasteride to put in it to give people with oral side effects the same benifits as everyone else, but without the side effects.