what do you mean by would it work? You would have to study how all those ingredients and the delivery vehicles all work together and interact not a simple thing to do properly. You cant just grab some products that are each a mix of things throw them together and expect them to work as you want them to. Just use them separately as they were intended and designed to do then you know each is working if they ever worked to begin with seeing as how neither is FDA approved to stop male pattern baldness.