Good question. Short version from the published data: the minoxidil + finasteride combo has noticeably more evidence behind it than minoxidil + dutasteride as a topical.
Topical finasteride has a proper phase III trial behind it (0.25% spray, 2022). Hair counts improved about as much as with oral finasteride at 24 weeks, while the drop in blood DHT was much smaller than with the tablet. There are also smaller trials of finasteride mixed into a minoxidil solution, and these did better than minoxidil alone.
Topical dutasteride is mostly compounded, and the data are thin: small studies, different strengths and bases, and few long-term numbers. Most of the solid dutasteride scalp data comes from oral use or mesotherapy injections, not from leave-on solutions. Dutasteride also stays in the body for weeks, so if some of it is absorbed, it is slow to clear.
A few practical points:
- Many people start with finasteride + minoxidil and only move to dutasteride if they are still losing ground after 9 to 12 months.
- Quality varies between compounding pharmacies, so the strength in the bottle is not always what the label says.
- "Topical" does not mean zero systemic effect, especially with large volumes or daily overuse. Sticking to the measured dose (often 1 ml) matters.
- Women who are or may become pregnant should not handle either product, and kids and pets should not have contact with treated skin.
Worth running past a dermatologist, who can also take a baseline photo so you can judge progress honestly at 6 and 12 months.