- Reaction score
- 3,149
For everyone who just casually dismisses my opinion as "laughable" or "nonsense" (@h.I. ): please reread my post. If anything's unclear, message me and I'll do my best to rectify it. @FredTheBelgian , what you've done in the above post is what's known in the trade as a straw man. You have misrepresented my argument - though, in truth, my post was more a set of questions than a fully fledged thesis. As an immediate response: humans are "mean" to everyone. They bully each other, lie to them, hit them, steal from them, kill them etc. The harm they do to animals is also incalculable. The average American consumes something like 1000 cows in his lifetime. Collectively we have almost singlehandedly massacred the ozone layer, killed off hundreds of endangered species etc. Those are some pretty significant "meanies" imo. Why does all this suffering need to be perpetuated? What's wrong with never existing? I doubt there's anything I can say that'll make you change your opinion, but if you're feeling open minded, I'll write a clear, comprehensive post setting out a formal, easily followed argument, for you, h.I. and all my other critics to evaluate. Sound good?
But almost none of us can say that we don't make selfish decisions which harm the planet, the environment, nature and animals. Can you?
I could grow potatoes and live off a small piece of land, ditch my car, never go on holidays and stop eating meat but I don't. For completely selfish reasons.
So the only valid argument is how much damage you should be willing to sacrifice for a certain gain.
For some people children is almost one of the most important things to them. They will not regard saving the future of humanity over having a kid, simple fact.
Even if you round up 90% of the population to your cause, and 90% of us stopped having kids, those 10% will spread their still-willing-to-have-kids genes and within a century we'll be back to where we were except these people will all be baby crazy. Evolution doesn't allow us to choose our way out of existence.