Women judge men in the same way that men judge women, sexually. There are more attractive-looking women than there are men. Just at Slavic countries if you don't believe me.
Nothing has changed in this regard except for the fact that the average man has dropped significantly in quality disproportionately to how much women have followed suit.
When 75% of American men and 65% of American women are obese or at least overweight, and I'm pretty sure you're both American (most here are), you honestly expect us to believe that the issue is simply that women's standards are too high? We're supposed to be shocked and appalled at women at the fact that they then rate 80% of men unfuckable? I'm not surprised.
It's not like Chad just is able to jump out of bed in morning looking like Chad. Does Chad go out into the streets with a bad, disheveled haircut, and ketchup-stained hoodie and get women throwing themselves at him? No. Does he just have rippling abs and biceps from eating cheeseburgers and "genetics"? Also no. Genetics mean nothing if one doesn't actually put in effort to make the most of them and the reality is that the human body did not evolve to look bad. The opposite, in fact. If MOST guys give it a serious try, they can be at least attractive enough that finding at least a reasonably-attractive girl will be interested in them, sexually.
Now, don't get me wrong, behaviorally it is true that people are fucked up right now. It's true that forming families is drastically tougher than our ancestors had it, but this goes far beyond mere "looks" (looks actually probably have a lot less to do with it) as to why these problems exist. Why do these problems exist? Read one of my many "ebil not-zee" posts for that.
Regardless, the only solution is for men to become better.