I would agree with you, if all the negative bashing isn't based on conjecture and rumour.....but until the full release of the study and then going over it properly, you can have a basis for an informed opinion.
I don't think anyone on this thread is praising it to be some kind of miracle....most have their heads screwed on and know that it as best might maintain with some level of growth and at worst do nothing...but there is a constant stream of people that think they know better and keep telling everyone its either a scam or is rubbish.
If that's their opinion...fine...then why not move on after making your point? Makes me feel like they have other motives is all.
No sh*t! People want it to f*****g work!