No, I'm talking about the legal fees of Merck. A class action suit with 1000+ people would cost them tens of millions to litigate if fully drawn out. The fact that it settled for such a low amount tells you how weak the suit was.
If you mean the plaintiffs incurred major legal fees, I highly doubt it because they could of have gotten a lawyer who would have charged them zero legal fees. I mean in that 1100 people who sued, surely atleast 10% knew of lawyers who could assist with the case for minimal to no legal fees.
Merck would have had to incur a lot of Additional costs for legal fees because that would have been charged to their business, massive fees I'd expect for such a scale. If they weren't in the wrong, they would have looked to counter sue to recuperate those costs.
The reason the plaintiffs got paid out a low amount is probably because they were paid out only enough to cover their medical bills + some extra money to cover their inconvenience, which is probably what most only wanted. You can't expect to sue for hundreds of millions for things like depression or anxiety, low libido, etc.
Although these things can affect people lives greatly, the court would probably only consider paying out significant amounts if it was extremely severe to the point it's was life threatening. Of course, not the best measure for how much something affects people lives.
Other sexual and mental side effects are difficult to prove in court especially if they had stopped some time after stopping Finasteride. For example, testicular pain, brain fog, watery semen, reduced semen count, even increased anxiety and depression, although very bad, usually subside after stopping Finasteride after some time.
Proving ED and Genital Shrinkage in a court due to Finasteride is difficult because lawyers could always say that they did not conduct proper trials from the time the person started Finasteride so they can't say for sure. So another way Merck can easily get away.
Although this is obviously not a good measure because people could have genuinely gotten impotence/ED/genital shrinkage due to Finasteride and if that were the case, there would definitely have been millions paid out per person. I do believe people know their bodies better than anyone.
The court probably would have ruled in the favor of the plaintiffs however if they pursued the case because 1100 people all sueing for the same things definitely will raise a lot of concern.
Basically, if these people were in a clinical trial from the time they had started Finasteride and they then experienced side effects, it would be a whole different ball game where much harsher punishment would have been inflicted by the court towards Merck.
Merck got off relatively soft because they would have just had to pay off medical bills and increase their side effects profile. However, that doesn't mean the plaintiffs cases were weak or false in any way, it simply means they were not in a clinical trial/study/monitoring environment which could have tracked their decline in health since prior to Finasteride and up until the end of use of Finasteride. So it was just unfortunate for the plaintiffs.
There's also the obvious reason that bribery came into play whereby the judge got bought off.
Now just have an opened mind on this, in every country, every adult should be aware that if individuals have enough money, lawyers, scientists, and judges can be bought off. I actually know people who are just above middle class in terms of finances that were able to do this.
It's far more common with millionaires, and it's almost obvious to expect some corruption to happen when your dealing with a multi-billion dollar company like Merck.
Simple examples are how governments of every country have judges who are bought off.
However, as unfortunate as it was that the plaintiffs weren't in a clinical study environment during the duration of their Finasteride usage, I have provided several studies which were in clinical study environments by proper medical professionals who are qualified and have proved side effects at a much higher rate.