I hate to admit this, but that is a very important recap.
I said it several times and I will say it again. This thread was flooded by dudes who started needling and also started minoxidil (or finasteride) at the same time. This trial IS NOT the place to do that, and now the consequence is that it has clouded the judgment of lots of people here.
On the other hand, yes, a lot of alleged responders are just claiming that their hair "feels thicker" or "feels healthier". Come on, people. This is not the way, and of course those shouldn't count. Let's all make an effort and provide good, comparable pictures.
Even through this whole thing doesn't look too good, I will keep doing it until November and will monitor my progress with pics. I will also try the everyday approach locally and will let you know what happens.
Also
@roberta, what's your take on the evidence provided by the studies? Do you have any explanation for the failure to replicate their overall results here?