Oh yeah, sure you seem to have figured it out and the million of guys training just aren't smart enough to get it. Year after year after year. That's a big fat cope from me.
View attachment 167011
Another really uninformed opinion for a million reasons. Carl Froch had low body fat and an extremely solid bizeps, 100% he was working out. But you know why boxers are often wiry? Because they cut weight, because there are weight classes and more muscles and weight mean you have an immense advantage over otherwise evenly matched opponents. So no one wants to compete in the higher weight class and thus starves himself to avoid that. And no you cannot arbitrarily differentiate weight from muscle
mass. As the name is indicating, additional muscles are just additional functional weight.
But I could break your argument down even further than that. Boxing is a great combat sport and training in that makes you an expert in...well, boxing. Which is: punching someone with wrapped and cushioned hands and defending against his strikes. It can be a pleasing sport, but its rigid and limiting rule system removes it a lot from any real combat and even most other combat sports. In real fighting and combat sports with less limiting rules, clinching and wrestling become integral. Both aspects are technical as well, but they put an even higher emphasis on strength than mere boxing (in which muscle mass is already extremely important).
At a certain threshhold overcoming strength with better technique becomes exponentially hard, until it is virtually impossible no matter what IP Man movies and the like, like to pretend. When The Mountain sparred with Mc Gregor it looked as if a big brother playfought with his sibling and had to try hard not to hurt him by accident. And that's a guy who at that time never trained martial arts a day before in his life. Anyways a tangent as you yourself said...albeit a more interesting one than the main discussion.
Women say a lot of things to appear less superficial but more and more are openly admitting that they are attracted to a rather muscular build nowadays. I think the bottom line is this: Working out didn't improve your chances much, because you have several other drawbacks as you have repeatedly stated. That doesn't mean, that going to the gym won't help a lot of other men in slightly different situations, it just means that it is not magic.
Meanwhile being a scrawney f***** on a treadmill absolutely doesn't improve anybodys outlook on women, despite maybe (maybe!) a tiny, tiny subset of men with a very special type of super attractive look, that was given to them by god. All of them who would never spend a single day in their lives on a hairloss incel forum.
So don't have your workout programme inspired by Ronaldo's or Brad Pitt's, because you will never ever be him or be like him.