I think the guy criticizing him held his own pretty well. And his observations were valid.
The girl probably didn't want to talk to him, so the "cuck" told me: "Look man, you're a balding ginger, why are you trying to force yourself on her? It's embarassing!"
And yeah, it is, what is even more embarrassing is that Owen Cook manages to get into this petty fight while he's supposed to be the paragon of pick up and social wisdom.
One time during a night out, I managed to go home (well, her home) with a girl without saying much, just standing there on the side, while other guys tried to impress her by talking endlessly like ecstasy-powered moneys. One of them (the guy that brought her to the party) was actually a short ginger.
Of course the girl is always going to try to be polite, to smile, especially since the guy trying to impress is the one that took her out, but by looking at her face, I could tell that she was getting impatient. So once the guy was done with his monologue, I stepped in and it went like this:
Small talk about where she comes from, what we do for a living and a short discussion about male-female relationships. I ask her to go downstairs to sit down. 15 minutes later, I'm making out with her. An couple of hours later, I'm in her bed.
The idea that you have to behave like Owen Cook to elicit interest in a girl is just plain wrong. I think very few girls actually like extroverted guys. That's not the archetype you'll find in art that's mainly consumed by women. What they gravitate towards is the "strong silent type" that they find attractive. Think Ryan Gosling who's practically a mute in most of his performances.
If I had to act like RSD Tyler to get girls, I'd feel ashamed and embarrassed. And it's not like I haven't tried to put on that act. It can work occasionally and the girl will temporarily see you as daring and assertive, but at the end of the day when she starts reflecting back on it, you were just a clown who had to put on a show to compensate for his shortcomings. That's my take on it.