Uh Fred maybe it never works because they expect the last point about you, so clearly that's a stumbling block.
I know this is incredibly harsh Fred and I've said it before, but I really do think you must have a miserable or bland personality, if you think you can never win round a girl with charm, conversation and humour, then you must only be limited to basic chat. I mean 80% or even more guys I've ever known, only stand a chance by getting out there and really applying themselves to whatever girl in order to get anywhere. Hell even some girls are attracted to a particular guy and still expect to have some sort of connection personality-wise.
This bull**** fairytale land in which you've dreamt up of, where women just go around pulling the guys they want to ****, it's just not reality. You've probably seen a few examples of it and now you apply it to every single situation.
Even if girls are physically compatible with a guy, only 20% or even less of guys are universally agreed as attractive, so not only does the girl fancy him personally, she has to ensure that her friends will also fancy him, be jealous of her, and hold what she has in high esteem. You've admitted this many times before, girls care tremendously about what their friends think, and will be put off a guy by their friends opinion.
So with this comes a glaring discrepancy in your Fred Complex Thesis, you're saying women are physically compatible to guys, but this is irrelevant anyway as they also need their friends to fancy them. So what's the answer to that?
So why do more than 20% of guys get laid? Because they win girls over, they make them sacrifice their vision of a perfect looking guy that all their friends like, to going with a less desirable guy who they can actually talk to comfortably with. It happens, all the ****ing time, and by denying it, you're denying the vast majority of relationships around you, and you do it on purpose.