- Reaction score
- 892
Despite the presented pro-needing evidence is becoming overwhelming (THANKS a ton @chen!), there still seem to be some doubt.
Last time I have presented my view of the NEEDLING EARLY RESULTS DISAPPOINTMENT.
This time would like to do the same for NEEDLING EFFICACY SKEPTICISM.
SCIENTIFIC APPROACH
Needling should ideally be assessed with scientific approach, and claims backed up by evidence.
EVIDENCE PRO NEEDLING
Needling is among the best evidence-supported regrowth treatments:
STUDIES
INDIAN = https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3746236/
CHINESE = https://www.docdroid.net/Q4cnC2V/101080-at-1476417220171376094.pdf
WOUNDING NEEDLING (aka @74775446 method)
Responders Photo-evidence was presented in the post below (w/ procedure details):
https://www.hairlosstalk.com/intera...s-from-tressless.117746/page-348#post-1769722
MINOXIDIL ABSORPTION NEEDLING (aka @Somebody method)
+ daily / bi-daily,
+ w/ Roller gently (no blood),
+ applying Minoxidil right-after;
Responders Photo evidence:
@Somebody (NO regrowth w/ minoxidil alone)
View attachment 112878
@chen (regrowing slick-bald areas!)
View attachment 112879
UNSPECIFIED NEEDLING
A series of anecdotes were kindly presented by @MinervaCGI starting here:
https://www.hairlosstalk.com/intera...s-from-tressless.117746/page-104#post-1741802
Unfortunately the regimens are not complete - do you happen to have the original links @MinervaCGI?
Dermarolling + Nizoral:
View attachment 112880
Dermarolling + finasteride + MIN:
View attachment 112881
Dermarolling@1mm + MIN + Nizoral:
View attachment 112882
CONCLUSION
Based on the presented evidence, NEEDLING & minoxidil for a YEAR OR MORE w/ above methods appears to REGROW HAIR WITH MOST PEOPLE.
EVIDENCE AGAINST NEEDLING
I support skepticism of balding treatment with:
(1) evidence against it, or
(2) lack of convincing evidence (e.g. Trinov as of right now);
But with needling I am having a hard time to see either...
There are "it doesn't work" anecdotal accounts here and @2013 community trial, but to my knowledge:
- everyone without results has NOT fulfilled the NEEDILING REGIMENS above (mostly by quitting before the 1 year mark), and
- everyone that has fulfilled the NEEDLING REGIMENS has had results;
If this is not the case, I would be happy to learn about it.
@NEEDLING SKEPTICS
I am genuinely curious what motivates skeptics and am reaching out to you for an explanation:
after all what I'm after is a working treatment, not a temporary delusional consolation
Are you skeptical because you believe:
(1) RESULTS = due to Finasteride / Minoxidil, NOT Needling?
(2) NEEDLING EFFECTS = vanishing over Time?
(3) STUDIES = w/ Agenda / conflict of Interest?
(4) ANECDOTES = from rare good Responders?
(5) ANECDOTES = questionable (e.g. FUE, Toppik, reversed Timeline etc.)?
(6) PHOTOS = questionable due to Lighting / Hair length / Viewpoint / Combover etc.?
(7) COMBINATION of the above and / or something else?
Where possible, please kindly back up your claims with evidence.
FINAL THOUGHTS
Till convincing evidence against it is presented, NEEDLING w/ MINOXIDIL still seems the best regrowth option currently available. Therefore, will be drilling holes in my scalp for now - and wish the best of luck to all Needling Warriors out there!
@Helga @LongWayHome you don’t even deserve what remaining follicles you have left.
Longway... just needle or shut up. Nobody gives a f*** about your speculation on 2024.
Helga... you “long time lurker” you should be so proud of yourself for contributing now. Well done. You do deserve.
Bwaaaa go bake me a cake with your snowflakes and entitlement.