I don't want to hold
@WhitePolarBear accountable for everything that happens on here, but I think a lot of people relate to him and agree with his general attitude because the majority of guys on here rely on internet dating, which sounds like a tough thing to rely on if you aren't more than above average looking.
I feel that Fred's attitude reflects the general opinion of many here, and therefore the hatred of "confidence". Here is not even an overly exaggerated version of why so many people hate the word, and it's understandable:
"People peddle this idea that if you have
confidence you can equal a 9/10 slayer, it removes ugliness, shortness, baldness, and elevates you to a God."
Not at all true of course, but it's all relative in taking opportunities
in real life, not in online dating which is the main source for a significant number of posters/readers on this forum. David gave an example of how he missed an opportunity because of a lack of dealing with a situation, I'd extend it further that approaching or being an approachable conversationalist, gives you opportunities that you wouldn't normally get yourself into, and from there your attitude can be vital.
@shookwun is another guy who's had experience in online dating of course, but I feel he's more open to the idea of real life interactions and the difference your attitude can make (this is just the impression I'm getting from reading his posts recently, I don't want to speak for him and I could be wrong).
All things in moderation, and balance.
Going to any extreme is a cope, if you believe your personality has nothing to do with getting chicks, that's a cope because you can blame your looks, if you believe that pulling a girl is 90% the reason guys get laid, it's a cope for being deluded enough to remove looks completely, because you want to believe you can make it after all despite being an underdog.
It's a mix of both, looks are definitely more important, but personality can bump you up significantly, and more importantly it means you can take the opportunities when they come along.