By the way, I think that the three of you are mistaken in banning
@WhitePolarBear. I'm in favor of moderators banning people when they see the need to do it, but I think that the default should be temporary bans (30 days, 60 days, etc.). Permanent bans should be reserved for people such as morose vegetables and anybody shilling scam products.
I did not get along with Bear, Rudiger, and Hairblues 100% of the time, in fact I had severe fights with each of them and would have been enthusiastic for temp bans for some of them at times. Perma bans though can undermine the community.
In the case of Bear specifically, he is the most impactful poster of these boards in the past several years. His sharing of life experiences were invaluable and he was willing to discuss things. He could sometimes come off as nuts and perseverate too much on some things, but we all do that from time to time, and on the bright side he was willing to tackle ideas, willing to move forward, and the fact that his views and temperament were evolving meant that he was in fact receptive to new experiences and new thinking.
I hope that you guys reconsider, I think that it would look good on you.
I realize that it's hard to take advice from me. It might be irritating. I'm not a moderator. A few years ago, a different message board asked me to be a moderator, and I declined as I realized that it would take a lot of time and energy. I recognize that you guys have to make difficult lose-lose decisions from time to time, that the job is unpaid, and that you get more grief than gratitude. That said I've contributed a lot here and thus I feel entitled to having and sharing an opinion.
Overall I think that the moderation here is pretty good actually. I just think that temp bans should be the default and I think that cutting off Bear in particular is bad, he's like part of the furniture here. He's articulate, he has substantial life experience, not a sheep, and thus he can't be replaced.
ETA: By removing people's private conversations with him, you're punishing other posters as well.